Home | BaltimoreBrew.com

Community group pitches Amazon on a different site: “Center Baltimore”

The proposal, submitted to Amazon yesterday, has provoked a private rebuke by Mayor Catherine Pugh

Above: Kelly Cross stands at North Avenue and Charles Street, the focal point of his independent proposal to Amazon. (Mark Reutter)

Why not the center city?

Frustrated by the Pugh administration’s exclusive focus on Port Covington, a community group has called on Amazon to consider north-central Baltimore as a candidate for its planned second headquarters (HQ2) hub.

“Center City offers Amazon the most diverse range of building typologies and zoning options, allowing Amazon to build a 21st century campus within a compact, walkable and beautiful 19th century urban fabric,” the Old Goucher Community Association noted in a bid the group submitted yesterday to the Seattle-based online retailer.

The proposal has already triggered a rebuke by Mayor Catherine Pugh.

Kelly Cross, president of the Old Goucher group, said the mayor called the proposal “a joke” in a telephone message and said it had “no standing or support” from her administration.

Council President Bernard C. “Jack” Young was also critical, arguing in a phone call to Cross today that Old Goucher and other community groups had to present a united front in support of Port Covington.

“This is not about our competing with Port Covington, but highlighting how center Baltimore better conforms to the requirements issued by Amazon,” said Cross, who prepared the bid with the help of association vice president Jay Orr and other volunteers.

The proposal identifies 200 acres of land and 15 million square feet of real estate within a 1½-mile radius of North Avenue and Charles Street, ranging from State Center in Bolton Hill to the failed 25th Street Station project in Remington.

For example, Cross pointed out during a tour of the area yesterday with a reporter, City Schools is evaluating whether to vacate its North Avenue administrative headquarters, a handsome 215,000-square-foot property two blocks east of Charles Street.

On the west side of North Avenue, a longtime eyesore, the Madison North apartments, has been razed, opening up a strategic site opposite student housing owned by the Maryland Institute College of Art.

This map from the Old Goucher proposal shows potential Amazon sites in north central Baltimore. (Old Goucher Community Association)

This map from the Old Goucher proposal shows potential Amazon sites in north-central Baltimore. (Old Goucher Community Association)

Better Fit

Overall, center Baltimore better meets Amazon’s requirements than Port Covington, the three-page summary proposal argued, based on the retailer’s needs for a campus that has direct access to rail transportation, is within 45 minutes of an international airport, and includes top-notch educational institutions and cultural attractions.

“It’s a 13-minute train ride to BWI Thurgood Marshall Airport from Penn Station,” Cross pointed out, while Acela service whisks passengers to Capitol Hill in Washington in 35 minutes and Madison Square Garden in New York in under 2½ hours.

“Look at what else we have around North Avenue and Charles,” Cross enthuses, standing on a vacant lot of what was once a premier address.

“MICA and the University of Baltimore are at our doorstep. Within a two-mile circle lies the Johns Hopkins Homewood campus, the Johns Hopkins Medical complex, the University of Maryland professional schools and Coppin State University.”

Cross then ticked off the district’s cultural institutions (the newly-opened Parkway Theatre, the Lyric Opera House, the Joseph Meyerhoff Symphony Hall, the Baltimore Museum of Art).

There are recreational opportunities for Amazon newcomers at Druid Hill Park and –”if  given some attention” – the Jones Falls Valley. Plus hundreds of historic and unique townhouses available for the fraction of the price of real estate in other cities competing for the HQ2 prize.

Why only Port Covington?

“So why are we putting all of our eggs in the basket of Port Covington?” Cross asked.

Realizing that the Baltimore Development Corporation (BDC) and other “economic powers-that-be” were not about to consider any site other than Kevin Plank’s Port Covington property, the Old Goucher group decided to submit its own proposal.

“We talked to people in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and other places who told us that their cities were submitting multiple sites to Amazon. But that wasn’t happening here. City Hall decided it liked what it’s already given so much money to,” Cross said, referring to the $660 million in TIF tax incentives pledged to Port Covington.

While acknowledging that his group’s bid is, at best, a long shot, he also believes that the Pugh administration “missed the boat” in understanding Amazon’s needs and corporate culture.

“These guys aren’t looking for suburban locations. I don’t think they’ll wind up on a peninsula or in a place where they are reliant on commuter bus or a little light-rail spur built to connect them to the rest of the city.”

Mayor Silent on Incentives

The financial incentives that the Pugh administration has offered to Amazon remain private. Gov. Larry Hogan also has not revealed how the state will sweeten the deal except to disclose, through a spokesman, that Amazon will receive the “biggest incentive offer in the state’s history” if it decides to locate in Maryland.

“We’re not privy to what the city and state are offering Amazon,” Cross said, “but we’re confident that if Amazon picks Baltimore, whatever incentives the city and state have offered elsewhere, they’d be willing to offer in our part of the city.”

During a pep rally on Wednesday, Mayor Catherine Pugh ceremonially signed a cover letter pitching the Port Covington site, surrounded by officials from Sagamore Development, the real estate arm of Plank, the CEO of Under Armour.

Kelly Cross stands beside the old ice house at 24th Street and Hampden Avenue, a vacant site near to the 12 acres of land at the failed 25th Street Station project. In the distance, the office towers of State Center are visible. (Mark Reutter)

Kelly Cross stands next to the old ice house at 24th Street and Hampden Avenue. The historic vacant structure is located just south of the dormant 25th Street Station Walmart project. In the distance, the office towers of State Center are visible. (Mark Reutter)

Way to Reboot West Baltimore?

Two months ago, as well as during the 2016 mayoral race, Pugh pledged to focus her development efforts on African-American neighborhoods in west and northwest Baltimore that “have been neglected for decades.”

The Old Goucher proposal encompasses parts of Penn North, Mondawmin, Sandtown-Winchester and Upton where rioting broke out after the 2015 police-in-custody death of Freddie Gray.

“50,000 new jobs coming to center Baltimore as part of an Amazon relocation would have massive ripple effects in these neighborhoods,” Cross said.

In its proposals to Amazon, the group noted that Old Goucher and the other nearby neighborhoods are “by far the most racially and ethnically diverse part of Baltimore” and have a large number of residents with a bachelor’s degree or higher.

The mayor’s office was asked yesterday and again this morning about Old Goucher’s proposal, and how it might fit into the administration’s plans to devote more resources to neglected neighborhoods.

So far, there has been no response.

Most Popular