Inside City Hall
Baltimore guessing game: Who attended private meeting with Harrison?
The guest list for a controversial gathering at City Hall to meet Mayor Pugh’s police commissioner-designate has still not been released
Above: City Hall faces a huge revenue shortfall. (Mark Reutter)
Were you one of the small group of people invited to City Hall last Thursday for an exclusive meeting with Baltimore Police Commissioner designate Michael Harrison?
No? Don’t feel too bad.
Mayor Catherine Pugh’s office made no public announcement of it. Reporters weren’t told about it. And City Council members weren’t invited either, which rubbed some of them the wrong way.
“I’m glad the mayor’s office is connecting him with the community, but an equal effort could’ve been made to introduce him to the people who will actually be voting on him,“ wrote Councilman Bill Henry on the Baltimore Voters Facebook page the next day.
The Brew asked the mayor’s office last week who was at the meeting and got no answer.
Reached again today, mayoral spokesman James E. Bentley II said, “I don’t think we’re releasing that, but I will check.”
The reason why discussion of the intimate gathering took place on the Voters Facebook page is that its founder, David Troy, was one of the people who did get an invite.
“I think overall [Harrison] seems to have the experience, curiosity, and capacity to handle the complexities of this job,” Troy wrote in a 691-word post, which is where many people learned the meeting took place.
The Bolton Hill tech entrepreneur wrote his summary after what he described as “a brief one-hour introductory session between about 15 community members” and the designee.
“I think he is someone who would be open and accessible to members of the community,” Troy continued, in his generally positive account.
“I think we’ll see that proved out through the confirmation process,” Troy wrote. “He seems to have a warm character.”
Tripping Again on Transparency?
Troy’s post spawned furious criticism on his nearly 9,000-member site.
“Meeting the new commissioner before even the NAACP or the ACLU?” one commenter asked.
“So you were invited because you were trusted to go to Facebook with your large following and spread good words before constituents,” another charged.
A few mentioned an earlier private meeting Troy had with Pugh which he also posted about afterwards, counseling against “obstructing” the selection of Harrison and urging that “the best course is to proceed with Harrison in the confirmation process and to give him a thorough but fair vetting.”
“You were invited because you were trusted to go to Facebook with your large following and spread good words before constituents.”
Fueling the hard feelings is the fact that Pugh’s earlier efforts to name a police commissioner drew heavy criticism for its lack of transparency.
The mayor had promised an open community engagement process after Darryl De Sousa resigned last May, but that never happened. Pugh’s choice of Fort Worth police chief Joel Fitzgerald instead was revealed after a seven-month search conducted largely behind closed doors.
With her latest pick, New Orleans police chief Michael Harrison, Pugh promised to hold meetings in each of the city’s police districts.
Only now here was Harrison’s first community meet-and-greet conducted, so it seemed, in more secrecy.
Place for Political Discourse
Troy’s defenders stepped in over the weekend to respond.
“Really, this is f’ing hysterical,” one of them said. “David Troy marches to his own drummer as anyone who is even barely observant should know at this point . . . The bulk of his comments on the mayor have been highly critical.”
Another argued that City Hall should be commended for reaching out to Troy in order to get the broadest community engagement.
“Look at the amount of political discourse that happens on this page,” she wrote. “Look at the number of responses to THIS post alone.”
For his part, Troy said his inclusion in the meeting makes sense.
“I’m an engaged member of the community, with years worth of exposure to the issue, and with access to a large audience,” he said.
Names Leaking Out
Asked online who attended the meeting with him, Troy wouldn’t say. He deferred to Alexandra Smith, the mayor’s director of community engagement.
Participants were asked not to disclose the list while fellow attendees were being given time to share their thoughts with their contacts in the community.
“We were asked not to talk about it too much at this stage,” said another person at the meeting, Keisha Allen, president of the Westport Neighborhood Association. “It was a good first impression, but I will reserve my judgement on him until I can see how he answers questions from my community.”
Some attendees, like Michael Hilliard, community services director for the Harbel community organization in Northeast Baltimore, posted about the meeting before and after it took place.
“At first blush he is an impressive person with a great deal of experience in policing a city very similar to ours,” wrote Hilliard, a retired Baltimore Police Department major who lives in Baltimore County.
Other names of attendees remain a subject of speculation.
Meanwhile, what about the multiple meetings with Harrison out in the community that the mayor’s office has promised?
“The schedule is not final and was shared prematurely,” Bentley said, referring to a list of 10 dates and locations Troy posted last week.
Asked about controversy over Pugh’s decision to give him and others an early peek, Troy said his critics were wrong to call it “an attempt to curry favor.”
He said Thursday’s meeting represented “a good effort” by the mayor to get citizen feedback.
Her office, however, “mishandled” one aspect of the event by withholding – for four days now – the names of attendees.
“This was not something I knew they would do going into the meeting,” Troy said.
** UPDATE **
Shortly after this story was posted on Facebook, Dave Troy said he was posting this list – all the names he recorded at Thursday’s meeting – “in the interest of settling this question.” No official list of the attendees has yet been released by the mayor.
• Imam Earl El-Amin – Muslim cultural center
• Rabbi Daniel Burg – Beth Am Synagogue In Reservoir Hill
• Pastor Todd Yeary – Douglas Memorial Community Church and Chair of Community Relations Commission
• Donna Brown – Member of CJSJ
• Keisha Allen – Westport Community Association, former CRB member
• Michael Hilliard – Harbel Community Organization Program Director and former police major
• Matthew Johnson – Baltimore City Youth Commission, Chair of Access to Resources Committee
• Lydia Walther-Rodriguez – CASA de Maryland
• Saleem El-Amim, Living Classrooms
• Ava Pipitone – Baltimore Transgender Alliance
• Clayton Guyton – Rose Street Community center, former correctional officer